spot_imgspot_img

Colorado Supreme Court rules against fisherman’s ‘standing’ in river access case

(The Center Square) – What started as a man standing in a river fishing ended with the Colorado Supreme Court ruling he doesn’t have legal standing to sue to gain access to the water.

In a unanimous decision, the court ruled Roger Hill couldn’t ask the court to declare access for him to a segment of the Arkansas River. Hill argued when Colorado became a state in 1876, the riverbed was transferred from the federal government to the state. Therefore, Hill contended he was on state property when fishing in the river and not trespassing on private property.

“Hill argues that, because the river was navigable at statehood, the riverbed is public land owned by the State of Colorado,” the appeals court claim stated. “Thus, he, as a member of the public, is not trespassing by wading on the riverbed.”

After an initial loss in the court of appeals, Hill’s request for declaratory judgment was accepted by that court along with an interpretation of the criminal trespass statute. When appealed to the Supreme Court, it ruled the trespassing issue wasn’t within the scope of the case.

Hill, 81, alleged in court documents the owners of a home and the land overlooking his favorite fishing hole repeatedly “chased him off the property, sometimes with force. Specifically, Hill alleges that they threatened to have him arrested for trespass, threw baseball-sized rocks at him, and shot a gun at his fishing buddy.”

In writing the opinion for the court, Justice Melissa Hart noted the case produced hundreds of pages of briefs on public trust doctrine, equal footing doctrine and arguments on who is best positioned to determine legal policy on access to rivers.

“But those subjects are ultimately irrelevant to the issue before us,” Justice Hart wrote in the 11-page ruling. “Rather, this case requires us to answer just one question: whether Roger Hill has a legally protected interest that affords him standing to pursue his claim for a declaratory judgment ‘that a river segment was navigable for title at statehood and belongs to the State.’ He does not.”

In a brief filed with the Colorado Supreme Court in 2022, Colorado Democrat Attorney General Phil Weiser objected to the appeals court decision to give Hill the possibility of a declaratory judgment.

“This decision was wrong and, absent resolution by this Court, creates an unworkable process that threatens to upset long-settled arrangements governing water and river access,” Weiser wrote.

In an email to The Center Square, Chief Communications Officer Lawrence Pacheco wrote the Attorney General has no comment on the ruling.

DON’T MISS OUT

Be the first to know about the latest news, giveaways, events, and updates from The Black Chronicle!

We don’t spam! Read our privacy policy for more info.

spot_imgspot_img
spot_img

Hot this week

African and Caribbean Nations Call for Reparations for Slave Trade, Propose Global Fund

Nations across Africa and the Caribbean, deeply impacted by...

Health care company agrees to pay $22.5 million to settle claims of over billing

A health care company agreed to pay nearly $22.5...

Sports betting expert offers advice on paying taxes for gambling winnings

(The Center Square) – Tax season is underway, and...

Entertainment district benefits don’t outweigh the cost, economists say

(The Center Square) — Weeks later, after more details...

Business association ‘disappointed’ by WA L&I’s proposed workers comp rate hike

(The Center Square) – The Association of Washington Business...

Browns will move to Brook Park, Cleveland mayor says

(The Center Square) – The Cleveland Browns plan to...

Environmental agency suggests monitoring systems to detect air pollution

(The Center Square) — The Community Air Monitoring and...

Ruling on Illinois’ gun ban expected sometime after Monday

(The Center Square) – A ruling on whether Illinois’...

Nearly $10M spent in U.S. House District 14

(The Center Square) – In Georgia’s 14th Congressional District,...

Colorado lawmakers oppose increased federal control over National Guard

(The Center Square) - A bipartisan group of 124...

Lawmaker flags Sedona firearms ordinance ‘enforceability’

(The Center Square) – Arizona Rep. Quang Nguyen, R-Prescott...

Arizona tutoring program available until end of school year

(The Center Square) – The Arizona Department of Education's...

More like this
Related

Browns will move to Brook Park, Cleveland mayor says

(The Center Square) – The Cleveland Browns plan to...

Environmental agency suggests monitoring systems to detect air pollution

(The Center Square) — The Community Air Monitoring and...

Ruling on Illinois’ gun ban expected sometime after Monday

(The Center Square) – A ruling on whether Illinois’...

Nearly $10M spent in U.S. House District 14

(The Center Square) – In Georgia’s 14th Congressional District,...