19th century horse speeding, fire transport still carry $5 fine

(The Center Square) — Outdated and unenforced statutes clutter state law but languish on the books for decades, even though lawmakers agree they should be repealed.

State Rep. Tim Brennan, D-Doylestown, has sponsored the latest effort in House Bill 1543, which targets two pre-Civil War provisions that have long been forgotten.

Passed in 1836, it remains illegal to carry fire over a wooden bridge and to take horses or cattle over a wooden bridge faster than a walking pace. Anyone who does so must pay a $5 fine.

“Some laws no longer apply to our modern world yet remain on the books,” Brennan wrote in a legislative memo. “They clog up the system and hinder the efficient operation of our government. These laws are prime examples.”

Brennan wants to repeal the laws “in the interest of maintaining an efficient and responsive government.”

- Advertisement -

Though it’s doubtful that anyone has paid a fine for speedy cattle on a wooden bridge in more than a century, the state legislative system doesn’t make repealing the law easy.

“You have to go through the same process to repeal a piece of law as you do to make a piece of law, and it’s not very easy to make a piece of law,” Brennan said.

Periodically, a repeal bill will make its way through the General Assembly, but it’s not a result of an annual auditing process.

“I don’t think there’s any systematic effort to look at that,” Brennan said. “At times when we’re doing a review of a portion of a law, people will see them and pull them out.”

Some outdated laws that get revoked can be irrelevant, but others can have a major impact.

Federal law penalizes the misuse of the anti-littering slogan “give a hoot, don’t pollute.” Massachusetts, however, repealed some 19th-century laws that penalized abortion in 2018 over concerns that a change in federal law could affect state law. In 2021, Congress repealed a number of laws pertaining to federal Indian policy.

- Advertisement -

Some small-government advocates have argued for decades for a Committee of Repeal in “every legislative body” to avoid confusion and ensure legislatures, rather than courts of an executive bureaucracy, craft law. Others have argued that “sunset laws” could automatically clean up laws by requiring re-authorization or else a law would expire.

“America’s massive, convoluted, rigid legal structure makes it almost impossible for government to do this job sensibly and within budget,” the lawyer Philip K. Howard argued in The Atlantic.

Hot this week

African and Caribbean Nations Call for Reparations for Slave Trade, Propose Global Fund

Nations across Africa and the Caribbean, deeply impacted by...

Sports betting expert offers advice on paying taxes for gambling winnings

(The Center Square) – Tax season is underway, and...

Health care company agrees to pay $22.5 million to settle claims of over billing

A health care company agreed to pay nearly $22.5...

Entertainment district benefits don’t outweigh the cost, economists say

(The Center Square) — Weeks later, after more details...

Business association ‘disappointed’ by WA L&I’s proposed workers comp rate hike

(The Center Square) – The Association of Washington Business...

Fiscal hawks: House budget plan could add $25 trillion in debt over next decade

House leaders have praised their early work on crafting...

The Hydrocodone Hyperbole: The Best Drug For Pain Isn’t Always An Opioid

Even though opioids are highly addictive, they continue to...

Cornell evaluating Trump’s DEI executive order, NYU has no comment

(The Center Square) – Cornell University is evaluating President...

Illinois one of the leaders in generating tax revenue from sports gambling

(The Center Square) – Illinois is one of several...

Feds, some lawmakers tackle post-Madigan efforts to curb public corruption

Federal authorities and state lawmakers say they will keep...

Man pleads guilty to $1.5 million in SNAP fraud

(The Center Square) – An Illinois man pleaded guilty...

Illinois lawmakers zoom in on budget ahead of governor’s address

(The Center Square) – Illinois lawmakers have differing budget...

Inflation hits Illinois consumers hard, especially in Chicago area

(The Center Square) – According to a new report,...

More like this
Related

Fiscal hawks: House budget plan could add $25 trillion in debt over next decade

House leaders have praised their early work on crafting...

The Hydrocodone Hyperbole: The Best Drug For Pain Isn’t Always An Opioid

Even though opioids are highly addictive, they continue to...

Cornell evaluating Trump’s DEI executive order, NYU has no comment

(The Center Square) – Cornell University is evaluating President...

Illinois one of the leaders in generating tax revenue from sports gambling

(The Center Square) – Illinois is one of several...