spot_imgspot_img

Judge orders St. Louis to stop guaranteed basic income payments

(The Center Square) – A judge ordered the City of St. Louis to stop its guaranteed basic income program, possibly marking the first time a court granted an injunction to stop payments.

St. Louis Circuit Court Judge Joseph Whyte ordered St. Louis Comptroller Darlene Green, Treasurer Adam Layne and Mayor Tishaura Jones to immediately stop making any deposits to financial institutions for funding the project, except for administrative costs, and stop all payments to private individuals under the program.

Two weeks ago, Judge Whyte granted a temporary order to stop the payments as part of a lawsuit filed by Greg Tumlin, a counselor, and Fred Hale, the former chairman of the Republican party in the city.

Whyte heard more than three hours of testimony in a hearing last week regarding the requested injunction.

“Insufficient evidence and argument was presented from which the court can find the necessary probability of success on the merits, threat of irreparable harm, the balance between harm and injury, and the public interest regarding these funds,” Whyte wrote in a 13-page order.

Bevis Schock, an attorney representing the taxpayers, said professors from Washington University’s Brown School of Social Work testified during the hearing along with two recipients and Judge Whyte ignored most of the testimony when he wrote the order.

“Interestingly, the professor has a contract with the city to study this,” Schock said in an interview with The Center Square. “So he was a witness and we exposed that bias. Of course he’s in favor of it. He’s paid to study it.”

Judge Whyte is allowing private donations from individuals to the city to fund the program to continue being used. Approximately 500 households were receiving $500 monthly payments as part of the federal pandemic American Rescue Plan Act funding. Dozens of cities are executing similar universal basic income programs.

“The city will follow the guidelines set forth by the court’s ruling and we are working with our partner organization to continue this program using private dollars while this case continues in court,” Jones said in a statement. “We remain committed to arguing our case on the merits, as we believe that this program serves a public good.”

Whyte wrote in his order the injunction is based solely on the question of the program violating the Missouri Constitution and the St. Louis City Charter.

“As noble as Ordinance No. 71591’s cause may be, it’s not what the court is being asked to decide,” Whyte wrote. “The court is only being asked to decide the constitutionality and legality of the ordinance.”

Schock emphasized the lawsuit focuses on whether the payments violate the law.

“Gratuitous payments to private individuals are not allowed and there’s good reasons for that,” Schock said. “The public eye tends to be insufficiently close on municipal government and a lot of hanky panky goes on. Otherwise, we could have mayors taking their brother-in-law to dinner and claiming it as a business expense. Or maybe the mayor decides to pay his mortgage for him. … We’re agnostic on the policy issue. I have my own opinion on the policy. But I’m in favor of charity.”

DON’T MISS OUT

Be the first to know about the latest news, giveaways, events, and updates from The Black Chronicle!

We don’t spam! Read our privacy policy for more info.

spot_imgspot_img
spot_img

Hot this week

African and Caribbean Nations Call for Reparations for Slave Trade, Propose Global Fund

Nations across Africa and the Caribbean, deeply impacted by...

Health care company agrees to pay $22.5 million to settle claims of over billing

A health care company agreed to pay nearly $22.5...

Sports betting expert offers advice on paying taxes for gambling winnings

(The Center Square) – Tax season is underway, and...

Entertainment district benefits don’t outweigh the cost, economists say

(The Center Square) — Weeks later, after more details...

Business association ‘disappointed’ by WA L&I’s proposed workers comp rate hike

(The Center Square) – The Association of Washington Business...

Report: Ohio mortgage rates increasing more than other states

(The Center Square) – Ohio’s average mortgage rate is...

GOP county clerks assure Michigan voters of election integrity, safeguards

(The Center Square) – Republican local election officials and...

Louisiana lawmakers hold first of two days of hearings on tax reform

(The Center Square) — On Tuesday, the House Ways...

Rivian production lines reduced due to supply shortage

(The Center Square) – Rivian production lines have reduced...

Georgia’s high school graduation rate improves

(The Center Square) – Georgia's high school graduation rate...

Dodgers starting pitcher robbed of $100K watch while at horse race track

(The Center Square) - Dodgers starting pitcher Walker Buehler...

Heat ‘distress’ leads to migrant rescue in Yuma Sector

(The Center Square) – Migrants in the Yuma sector...

Deficit nears $2 trillion as lawmakers borrow $5 billion per day

(The Center Square) – The U.S. annual deficit is...

More like this
Related

Report: Ohio mortgage rates increasing more than other states

(The Center Square) – Ohio’s average mortgage rate is...

GOP county clerks assure Michigan voters of election integrity, safeguards

(The Center Square) – Republican local election officials and...

Louisiana lawmakers hold first of two days of hearings on tax reform

(The Center Square) — On Tuesday, the House Ways...

Rivian production lines reduced due to supply shortage

(The Center Square) – Rivian production lines have reduced...