Opponents on minor gender dysphoria care feel medicine is on their side

The question before the U.S. Supreme Court on Wednesday was whether a Tennessee law banning gender dysphoria treatment for minors is unconstitutional.

Twenty-three other states have similar bans, but the Tennessee case is the first one to have made it to the nation’s highest court.

Behind the legal questions debated are medical questions that are in dispute.

A transgender girl identified as “L Williams” is at the center of the case brought by the American Civil Liberties Union and later supported by the Biden administration. In an article posted on the ACLU’s website, L said she was emotionally distressed as she began puberty.

“You’re at a point where not only are you going through puberty, but you’re also going through nightmare puberty,” L said. “I mean, obviously, nobody’s 100% comfortable with [the changes,] but you’re immensely uncomfortable with them.”

- Advertisement -

L’s parents sought puberty and hormone blockers in another state when Tennessee lawmakers passed its ban in 2023. They were on the steps of the U.S. Supreme Court when the case was argued.

Also on the steps was Dr. Jared Ross, a member of Do No Harm, a group of medical professionals who say their mission is to keep identity politics out of medical education, research, and clinical practice.

Ross has a story, too, about a blue-haired girl who came into an emergency room one night. She described herself as “gender-confused,” Ross said in an interview with The Center Square.

“She was cutting herself with a razor blade because voices were telling her to,” Ross said. “Can you imagine if I had affirmed these voices, affirming what she was hearing? That would have been malpractice, that would have been criminal. I didn’t affirm those voices. I also didn’t affirm her gender confusion.”

Do No Harm filed an amicus brief challenging the medical evidence presented by the ACLU and the Biden administration. It points to a study called the “Cass Review,” a multi-year project from the United Kingdom that said studies of the use of puberty blockers and cross-sex hormones were uncontrolled observational studies subject to bias.”

The ACLU says it also has medical evidence on its side. The American Medical Association and the American College of Pediatrics are among the groups that support gender dysphoria treatment for minors.

- Advertisement -

At least one medical organization is taking a second look at the treatments. The American Society of Plastic Surgeons said in April that it is reviewing the practice.

“ASPS currently understands that there is considerable uncertainty as to the long-term efficacy for the use of chest and genital surgical interventions for the treatment of adolescents with gender dysphoria, and the existing evidence base is viewed as low quality/low certainty. This patient population requires specific considerations,” the organization said in a statement.

Doctors who don’t support treatments for gender dysphoria for minors are accused of discrimination and not caring about the patients.

But that’s not the case, Ross said.

“The other side often plays this as we’re neglecting these kids or we’re minimizing their suffering that they’re going through,” Ross said. “I don’t doubt that they’re suffering. They’re suffering tremendously. They need love and compassion and good evidence-based mental health care.”

Until the Supreme Court rules in 2025, the Tennessee law and others like it will stay on the books.

Hot this week

African and Caribbean Nations Call for Reparations for Slave Trade, Propose Global Fund

Nations across Africa and the Caribbean, deeply impacted by...

Sports betting expert offers advice on paying taxes for gambling winnings

(The Center Square) – Tax season is underway, and...

Health care company agrees to pay $22.5 million to settle claims of over billing

A health care company agreed to pay nearly $22.5...

Entertainment district benefits don’t outweigh the cost, economists say

(The Center Square) — Weeks later, after more details...

Business association ‘disappointed’ by WA L&I’s proposed workers comp rate hike

(The Center Square) – The Association of Washington Business...

Report: Texas is building more new homes than any other state

(The Center Square) – Texas is building more new...

Op-Ed: How to get the most Tennessee children access high-quality private education

The Tennessee Legislature finally has acceded to the request...

January sports wagering revenue up 108.7% in North Carolina

(The Center Square) – January yielded the third highest...

Florida legislative leaders, governor reach deal on immigration enforcement

(The Center Square) – Florida legislative leaders and Gov....

Fort Bragg back on world’s largest military installation

(The Center Square) – Posthumously honoring a soldier from...

More like this
Related

Report: Texas is building more new homes than any other state

(The Center Square) – Texas is building more new...

Op-Ed: How to get the most Tennessee children access high-quality private education

The Tennessee Legislature finally has acceded to the request...

January sports wagering revenue up 108.7% in North Carolina

(The Center Square) – January yielded the third highest...