spot_imgspot_img

New York attorney general loses court fight against PepsiCo over plastic pollution

spot_img

(The Center Square) — A New York State judge has tossed out a lawsuit against PepsiCo that sought to hold the company accountable for plastic pollution in the Buffalo River and chided Democratic Attorney General Leticia James for “policy idealism” by filing the legal challenge.

The ruling by New York Supreme Court Justice Emilio Colaiacovo sided with the beverage giant’s argument that it couldn’t be held responsible for polluting the river, as it was consumers who tossed away the plastic bottles and other trash into the water body.

James filed the lawsuit against Pepsi and FritoLay last year, alleging that the company was “jeopardising the environment and public health” by producing large numbers of single-use plastic containers. The legal challenge focused on pollution in New York’s Buffalo River, which is used as a source of drinking water.

Colaiacovo scoffed at James’ allegations as “speculative” and said it would be “contrary to every norm of established jurisprudence” to punish PepsiCo because it was people, not the company, who tossed litter into the river.

“It is important to note that regardless of the defendant’s aspirational goals, Pepsi/Frito Lay did not pollute the Buffalo River or any other local waterways – other people did,” he wrote. “Instead of pursuing those who commit the act, the Attorney General wishes to penalize those who produce the discarded item. This theory has never been adopted by a court in this state or any other.”

James’ lawsuit called for civil penalties and restitution “for the damage inflicted upon New York’s communities and environment.” It also called for a ban on PepsiCo selling or distributing single-use plastic bottled products in the Buffalo region without warning consumers that “the packaging is a potential source of plastic pollution and presents a risk of harm to human health and the environment.”

But Colaiacovo also criticized James for ignoring a 2003 New York Appeals Court’s decision in a lawsuit filed by predecessor, Eliot Spitzer, which declined to hold Sturm Ruger liable for criminals who use its firearms to commit violence. He said James’ legal challenge risks “opening the floodgates” to public nuisance lawsuits.

“While I can think of no reasonable person who does not believe in the imperatives of recycling and being better stewards of our environment, this does not give rise to phantom assertions of liability that do nothing to solve the problem that exists,” Colaiacovo wrote. “The judicial system should not be burdened with predatory lawsuits that seek to impose punishment while searching for a crime.”

In a statement, PepsiCo welcomed the court’s decision and said it is “serious” about expanding recycling efforts and reducing the use of single-use bottles and other plastic products.

“We will continue to collaborate with key partners to advance smart material collection policies, improve recycling infrastructure, boost consumer awareness about the importance of recycling and establish partnerships focused on reducing waste and exploring innovative solutions to plastic pollution,” the company said.

The attorney general’s office said it was “disappointed” by the judge’s ruling and is reviewing its options but remains “committed to protecting communities from the dangers of plastic pollution.”

“Plastic pollution poses a major threat to our planet and our public health,” a James spokesperson said in a statement.

DON’T MISS OUT

Be the first to know about the latest news, giveaways, events, and updates from The Black Chronicle!

We don’t spam! Read our privacy policy for more info.

spot_img
spot_img

Hot this week

African and Caribbean Nations Call for Reparations for Slave Trade, Propose Global Fund

Nations across Africa and the Caribbean, deeply impacted by...

Health care company agrees to pay $22.5 million to settle claims of over billing

A health care company agreed to pay nearly $22.5...

Sports betting expert offers advice on paying taxes for gambling winnings

(The Center Square) – Tax season is underway, and...

Entertainment district benefits don’t outweigh the cost, economists say

(The Center Square) — Weeks later, after more details...

Business association ‘disappointed’ by WA L&I’s proposed workers comp rate hike

(The Center Square) – The Association of Washington Business...

Changes enacted to North Carolina juvenile delinquent law

(The Center Square) – Some parts of juvenile delinquent...

Wikler tosses hat into national chairman ring

(The Center Square) – Wisconsin’s Democratic Party leader is...

King County Councilmember Girmay Zahilay joins county executive race

(The Center Square) – Metropolitan King County Councilmember Girmay...

Audit finds Louisiana improved its response time to abuse complaints

(The Center Square) — The Louisiana Department of Health...

Illinois quick hits: Pritzker names early childhood director

Pritzker names early childhood director ...

Duo indicted for faking ESA application documents

(The Center Square) – Individuals in an Empowerment Scholarship...

Op-Ed: The real climate crisis is about power, not just energy

A small nation's defiant exit from COP29 has exposed...

Challenging Trump, California to pay for migrant deportation defense

(The Center Square) – U.S. Sen. Alex Padilla, D-Calif.,...

More like this
Related

Changes enacted to North Carolina juvenile delinquent law

(The Center Square) – Some parts of juvenile delinquent...

Wikler tosses hat into national chairman ring

(The Center Square) – Wisconsin’s Democratic Party leader is...

King County Councilmember Girmay Zahilay joins county executive race

(The Center Square) – Metropolitan King County Councilmember Girmay...

Audit finds Louisiana improved its response time to abuse complaints

(The Center Square) — The Louisiana Department of Health...