Op-Ed: Due process disappears when King County seizes and keeps property

People should not lose their property without due process. But a new government audit shows widespread disregard for civil rights when the King County Sheriff’s Office seizes and permanently keeps cash, cars, and other valuables.

Many property owners lose their belongings without an arrest, conviction, or hearing before a neutral judge. Police and prosecutors dodge due process using civil forfeiture, a law enforcement maneuver that leaves property owners with no right to counsel or guarantee of trial.

In the rare cases that goes to court, the government merely has to link property to wrongdoing by a preponderance of the evidence, a standard of proof far below the “beyond a reasonable doubt” threshold needed for a criminal conviction.

Rather than contest the forfeiture in court, many property owners opt for an administrative resolution to save money. Others walk away and lose by default. “Almost all claims are apparently settled prior to a hearing or trial,” the audit finds, which means the county does not have to prove anything by any standard.

Once a civil forfeiture case ends, Washington allows state and local agencies to keep 90% of the proceeds for themselves. The result is a perverse incentive to police for profit. King County Auditor Kymber Waltmunson calls the scheme a “high-dollar practice.”

- Advertisement -

This is an understatement. Since 2017, the King County Sheriff’s Office has forfeited over $9 million in cash, 41 houses, and 120 cars. Statewide, Washington agencies forfeited more than $232 million during the 20 years from 2000 to 2019.

The full scope of the abuse in King County is hard to gauge. Concerned citizens have no idea, and neither does the sheriff. The audit describes outdated tracking methods that leave everyone in the dark.

King County keeps records in paper folders with key information missing, making meaningful analysis difficult. The state never asks for a report, anyway. Washington has no central oversight body, collects no expenditure data, and publishes no annual civil forfeiture summary.

Money goes into the system. Then what happens is anyone’s guess.

“The Sheriff’s Office could not readily determine the total number of cases, the value of assets seized, how many cases were challenged, how many cases were removed to court, how many cases had associated criminal convictions, or how many assets were ultimately returned to their owners or forfeited to the Sheriff’s Office,” the audit finds.

Other problems exist. The report cites lack of independent hearings and confusing notices that incorrectly imply a presumption of guilt. “Under Washington state law, it is the Sheriff’s Office that must prove the property should be forfeited,” the audit states.

- Advertisement -

Despite this criticism, the audit gives the King County Sheriff’s Office credit for taking a “restrained approach” to civil forfeiture. Unlike many agencies, which use traffic stops as a pretext to grab cash, King County limits itself to “high-level” drug cases.

This misses the point. Even when a conviction occurs—something not guaranteed—civil forfeiture happens separately. This means property owners linked to wrongdoing must divide their attention between criminal and civil cases, which can overlap.

No kinder, gentler approach to civil forfeiture exists. It always leads to due process violations.

The solution is to end civil forfeiture and replace it with criminal forfeiture, a process that allows the government to seize and keep property as part of criminal proceedings.

New Mexico took this step in 2015 following litigation from our public interest law firm, the Institute for Justice. Alarmists predicted crime would spike. But a 2024 study shows no negative effects.

Crime should not pay. But the government goes too far when it tramples due process by punishing innocent people as though they are guilty.

Dan Alban is a senior attorney and co-director of the National Initiative to End Forfeiture Abuse at the Institute for Justice in Arlington, Va. Daryl James is an Institute for Justice writer.

spot_img
spot_img

Hot this week

African and Caribbean Nations Call for Reparations for Slave Trade, Propose Global Fund

Nations across Africa and the Caribbean, deeply impacted by...

Sports betting expert offers advice on paying taxes for gambling winnings

(The Center Square) – Tax season is underway, and...

Health care company agrees to pay $22.5 million to settle claims of over billing

A health care company agreed to pay nearly $22.5...

Entertainment district benefits don’t outweigh the cost, economists say

(The Center Square) — Weeks later, after more details...

Business association ‘disappointed’ by WA L&I’s proposed workers comp rate hike

(The Center Square) – The Association of Washington Business...

Everyday Economics: Brace yourself for higher market volatility this week

This week’s data will offer fresh clues on the...

Trouble Sleeping? This Science-Backed App Could Change Your Life

Sleep quality is a huge determinant of our health,...

Op-Ed: Hispanic families in New Mexico push back on gender policies

In a state where more than 1 million residents...

Senate committee to vote on bills combating antisemitism on campuses

Legislation targeting harassment of Jewish students at higher education...

The FDA Is Failing – Here’s What Needs To Change

We’ve long trusted the FDA to protect public health,...

Illinois bill helps homeowners fight back against squatters

(The Center Square) – With instances of squatting sharply...

Voters focused on prices, tariffs as Trump wraps up first 100 days

American voters are focused on prices, tariffs and illegal...

WATCH: Trump, Rubio say Russia-Ukraine war is ‘endable’

President Donald Trump and Secretary of State Marco Rubio...

More like this
Related

Everyday Economics: Brace yourself for higher market volatility this week

This week’s data will offer fresh clues on the...

Trouble Sleeping? This Science-Backed App Could Change Your Life

Sleep quality is a huge determinant of our health,...

Op-Ed: Hispanic families in New Mexico push back on gender policies

In a state where more than 1 million residents...

Senate committee to vote on bills combating antisemitism on campuses

Legislation targeting harassment of Jewish students at higher education...