Justices unanimous: Minnesota county used debt to leverage more than owed

(The Center Square) – Citing violation of the Fifth Amendment, the U.S. Supreme Court unanimously declared a Minnesota county in violation for its actions after a 94-year-old’s condominium was sold at auction.

Following the 2016 sale for $40,000, Hennepin County kept all that was left over after the $15,000 in taxes, penalties and costs that Geraldine Tyler owed.

“A taxpayer who loses her $40,000 house to the State to fulfill a $15,000 tax debt has made a far greater contribution to the public fisc than she owed,” Chief Justice John Roberts wrote in his majority opinion. “The taxpayer must render unto Caesar what is Caesar’s, but no more.”

The county’s case banked on a 1935 state law, one which takes away the homeowner’s interest in the property if the homeowner falls behind on property taxes. Roberts noted that the state of Minnesota “recognizes that in other contexts a property owner is entitled to the surplus in excess of her debt.” He said the county couldn’t use the debt amount to leverage more than owed.

Justices cited the U.S. Constitution’s Takings Clause, which prohibits the government from taking private property without just compensation.

- Advertisement -

Tyler’s unpaid bill was $2,300, to which $12,700 was added in late fees and penalties.

Pacific Legal Foundation attorney Christina Martin argued the case before the Court.

“Today’s decision is a major victory for property rights in the United States,” Martin said. “This decision affirms that property rights are fundamental and don’t depend solely on state law. The Court’s ruling makes clear that home equity theft is not only unjust, but unconstitutional.”

Justice Neil Gorsuch was joined by Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson for a concurring opinion, noting the U.S. Constitution’s Excessive Fines Clause.

“Economic penalties imposed to deter willful noncompliance with the law are fines by any other name,” Gorsuch wrote. “And the Constitution has something to say about them: They cannot be excessive.”

spot_img
spot_img

Hot this week

African and Caribbean Nations Call for Reparations for Slave Trade, Propose Global Fund

Nations across Africa and the Caribbean, deeply impacted by...

Sports betting expert offers advice on paying taxes for gambling winnings

(The Center Square) – Tax season is underway, and...

Health care company agrees to pay $22.5 million to settle claims of over billing

A health care company agreed to pay nearly $22.5...

Entertainment district benefits don’t outweigh the cost, economists say

(The Center Square) — Weeks later, after more details...

Business association ‘disappointed’ by WA L&I’s proposed workers comp rate hike

(The Center Square) – The Association of Washington Business...

WATCH: IL family fighting state to keep child with disabilities closer to home

(The Center Square) – A southern Illinois family is...

55,000 LA County employees go on strike as county cuts spending, avoids layoffs

(The Center Square) - Fifty-five thousand Los Angeles County...

WATCH: Illinois In Focus Daily | Tuesday April 29th, 2025

(The Center Square) – In today's edition of Illinois...

‘Main Street, not Wall Street’: Trump defends tariffs, touts immigration success

President Donald Trump delivered remarks at a rally in...

1,786 Wisconsin deer tested positive for chronic wasting disease in 2024

(The Center Square) – There were 1,786 deer that...

Report: WA wealth tax would not cause ‘mass exodus of millionaires’

(The Center Square) – A novel tax proposal out...

Louisa County Board of Supervisors approve $187.6M budget

(The Center Square) – Louisa County, Va. supervisors unanimously...

More like this
Related

WATCH: IL family fighting state to keep child with disabilities closer to home

(The Center Square) – A southern Illinois family is...

55,000 LA County employees go on strike as county cuts spending, avoids layoffs

(The Center Square) - Fifty-five thousand Los Angeles County...

WATCH: Illinois In Focus Daily | Tuesday April 29th, 2025

(The Center Square) – In today's edition of Illinois...